Isotropic Gaussian Processes Improve Vanilla Bayesian Optimization in High Dimensions

Wei-Ting Tang, Madhav Muthyala, Joel A. Paulson

High-dimensional Bayesian optimization (BO) often fits Gaussian process (GP) surrogates from far fewer observations than input dimensions. Modern Vanilla BO can perform well in this regime with dimension-aware priors, initialization, and acquisition optimization, but it typically retains automatic relevance determination (ARD), fitting one lengthscale per input coordinate. We study this modeling choice and propose Iso-BO, a controlled modification that replaces the ARD GP with an isotropic GP using one shared lengthscale while keeping the surrounding BO pipeline matched. For radial kernels, we show that the marginal log likelihood (MLL) depends on the inverse-squared ARD lengthscales only through weighted pairwise distances among the observed inputs. The current design can therefore leave some ARD directions exactly invisible or only weakly constrained by the MLL. Iso-BO removes coordinatewise reweighting and fits a single shared scale instead. Lengthscale-fitting and predictive-density diagnostics show that this finite-data effect appears in practice, including when the data-generating process is anisotropic. Across GP-prior, synthetic, and real-world benchmarks, Iso-BO often…